Russian nuclear threats
Russia has threatened nuclear war perhaps 6 or 7 times in the past week. Are the threats serious, and why is Russia making them?
In the past week, Russian government officials have threatened nuclear war a good seven or so times. Former Russian president and prime minister Dmitry Medvedev made around three different nuclear threats on his own, and the other four came from Putin, defense minister Shoigu, foreign minister Lavrov, and a deputy foreign minister.
Then, for good measure, Putin announced/claimed he was moving tactical (small) nuclear weapons to the neighboring country of Belarus, run by a pro-Putin dictator.
The question is why all this is happening, and whether the threat is even real.
Spoiler alert, to put your mind at ease: I think Putin is bluffing. He’s never going to use nukes in Ukraine, nor is he likely to even move tactical nuclear weapons into Belarus. All the defense experts agree that Putin gains no military advantage by using such weapons. It won’t help the Russians on the battlefield, as Ukraine troops aren’t all bunched up in one place. Use of a nuke would likely only further steel Ukrainian resolve. It would probably force China and India to break with Russia. It would irradiate land that Russia considers Russian, and that Russia hopes to occupy. And finally, use of even small nuclear weapons in Ukraine would likely force NATO to enter the war. And NATO’s conventional forces could/would wipe Russia from the map.
So why are the Russians making the threat? The same reason they’ve been threatening nuclear war on a nearly weekly basis since the invasion began: We’re in day 397 of Putin’s 10-day war, and he needs something to change the dynamic. His only hope is getting NATO to think the risk of escalation is too high, and thus we pressure Ukraine to settle. At the very least, Putin is trying to provide propaganda fodder for the extreme left and MAGA right. He wants to give Donald Trump, Ron DeSantis, Fox News and Elon Musk something they can publicly fret over, in the hopes that it eventually convinces the American people, and thus their elected representatives, that this war is too risky to continue.
In the end, if Putin were truly going to use nuclear weapons, he wouldn’t be threatening to use them multiple times a week for the past 397 days, and then do nothing. He’s losing this war — or, at the very least, sees no credible way of winning it — and is now trying to psych us out of continuing our support. The strategy will certainly work with Trump, Tucker Carlson, and the extremist left. Let’s just hope that everyone else is able to see through the bluff, and continues supporting Ukraine to victory.
A few additional tidbits
Fox News host goes after Trump over the January 6 Insurrection:
The Nazis kidnapped children too:
Yes, AR-15s are more dangerous than handguns:
In response to Trump yet again defending Putin, GOP presidential candidate Mike Pompeo writes in supporting of supporting Ukraine:
Elon Musk’s Twitter has already loft half its value:
And finally, Ukrainian troops trolling Russian troops with an unarmed drone:
CyberDisobedience - by John Aravosis is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
I agree that Putin is bluffing.This is why I fully believe we should call his bluff. We must give Ukraine offensive weapons, otherwise this is going to drag on too long and Ukrainians are going to be the ones dying. When Japan attacked the US in 1941, we didn’t just defend our land, nor did the Brits “just defend” their land through the constant bombing of civilians in London.
The Russians have mounted a terror campaign against the civilians in Ukraine. The only way for this to end is for the military leadership in Russia to see there is no winning, and they will introduce Mr. Putin to a fifth floor window in Moscow.
Even Brian Kilmeade criticizing Trump! Not that any of this will stop Trump from winning the nomination. But if he does somehow lose the nomination, is there any reason on earth he WOULDN'T run third party so he can keep raising money? Or is it just too much bother?
As for Putin and nukes, he's the boy who cried wolf wolf wolf wolf wolf wolf wolf wolf wolf wolf wolf wolf wolf wolf wolf wolf wolf wolf wolf wolf wolf wolf wolf wolf wolf wolf wolf wolf wolf wolf wolf wolf!